What reviews are you looking at?
I saw a couple idiots on Youtube trying to say it wasn't all that great at tracking... as they used the index controllers (which is why the tracking was bad).
The rest say it's a solid choice, a good upgrade and only lacks new style controllers.
Which is fine for me. Anyone that's actually any good at shooting games prefers the Vive controllers that you can hold the same way each time over the other controllers you have to strap to your hand which means you'll never get it centered or aiming exactly the same way twice.
